Irish Potato Candy – Authentic & Easy St. Paddy’s Day Treat

Irish Potato Candy is one of those treats that sounds like a joke until you actually try it. Spoiler: there are zero potatoes involved. But there is cinnamon, cream cheese, and coconut – and if that combo sounds weird, just wait. This delightfully old-school Philadelphia recipe is sweet, no-bake, and absolutely perfect for St. Patrick’s Day or, frankly, any Tuesday when you need something sugary and nostalgic.

The best part? You don’t need to fire up the oven, dig out your candy thermometer, or be any kind of expert. Irish Potato Candy is charmingly simple and wildly addictive, with its creamy coconut filling rolled in cinnamon until it looks just like a tiny spud. Whether you grew up in Philly or are just Irish by vibe, this is a recipe worth bookmarking – and sharing. If you love easy desserts like our Strawberry Loaf Cake or no-bake Strawberry Crunch Icebox Cake, you’re going to want in on this little cinnamon-dusted secret.

Table of Contents

What is Irish Potato Candy?

Despite the name, Irish Potato Candy has absolutely nothing to do with actual potatoes. Not even close. It’s a beloved Philadelphia confection traditionally made around St. Patrick’s Day, especially in neighborhoods where Irish-American heritage runs deep. Picture a ball of sweet, coconutty cream cheese filling that’s been lovingly rolled in cinnamon until it resembles a teeny, slightly grubby potato. Weird? Yes. Delicious? Absolutely.

Think of it like the candy version of a practical joke that tastes amazing. The origins of Irish Potato Candy are a little murky – some say it started as a fun St. Paddy’s treat in Irish immigrant communities, while others believe it was just a creative way to make a cheap, no-bake dessert with pantry staples. Whatever the history, one thing is clear: these little faux-spuds are now a staple in Philly kitchens and sweet shops every March. They’re simple, kid-friendly, and make a wonderful edible gift. If you enjoy quirky traditions and easy homemade candies, Irish Potato Candy deserves a spot on your spring baking list.

Reasons to Try Irish Potato Candy

There are about 75 good reasons to make Irish Potato Candy, and they’re all cinnamon-coated. But seriously, this treat ticks so many boxes. First off, it’s a no-bake dessert – and who doesn’t love skipping the oven? Whether your kitchen gets hot fast or you’re juggling three million things (hello, fellow moms), that’s a win. Secondly, this recipe is just plain fun. It’s like edible Play-Doh that actually tastes good. Roll up your sleeves and get the kids involved – they’ll love shaping the candy and getting cinnamon everywhere (you’ve been warned).

Third, Irish Potato Candy is surprisingly crowd-pleasing. The sweet coconut filling is creamy and rich, balanced perfectly by the warm spice of the cinnamon. Even folks who claim to hate coconut usually sneak a second (or third) one. Plus, it’s got novelty on its side. Serve these at a party and you’ll have people asking, “Wait, what’s in these?” before begging for the recipe. And finally, it makes a big batch – about 75 little candies – which means you can hand some out to friends, neighbors, or teachers. Or hoard them. No judgment.

Ingredients Needed to Make Irish Potato Candy

Here’s everything you need to whip up your own batch of Irish Potato Candy:

• 1 (8-ounce) package Philadelphia cream cheese, softened
• 1 stick (4 ounces or 8 tablespoons) unsalted butter, softened
• 32 ounces confectioner’s sugar (yep, the whole bag)
• 7 ounces sweetened shredded coconut
• 1½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract
• Pinch kosher salt (preferably Diamond Crystal)
• About 3 tablespoons ground cinnamon (give or take, for rolling)

Optional (but fun):

• A few pine nuts for “potato eyes”
• A 1:1 blend of cocoa powder and cinnamon if you want a darker, dirtier spud

Instructions to Make Irish Potato Candy – Step by Step

Step 1: Make the Creamy Coconut Base

Start your Irish Potato Candy adventure by pulling out your stand mixer (or grabbing a very sturdy wooden spoon and flexing those biceps). Toss in the softened cream cheese and butter. Cream them together on low speed until you have a soft, smooth mixture. Low is the key here unless you want a blizzard of powdered sugar in your face.

Once the butter and cream cheese are dreamy and lump-free, slowly add the confectioner’s sugar. Again, low speed. No one wants a sugar explosion on their shirt. Add it in batches so the mixer doesn’t get overwhelmed. By the time you’re done, you’ll have a thick, almost dough-like base that smells like sugar heaven.

Now comes the coconut. Add the sweetened shredded coconut, vanilla extract, and a tiny pinch of kosher salt. This salt may feel like a throwaway, but trust me, it brings out the sweetness and adds balance. Mix everything until well combined and smooth. Scrape the bowl a couple of times to make sure nothing sneaky is hiding at the bottom.

Pop that glorious dough into the fridge to chill for at least an hour. This makes it firm enough to scoop and shape without turning into a sticky mess. If you’re in a hurry, 30 minutes in the freezer also works in a pinch.

Step 2: Scoop, Roll, and Dust in Cinnamon

Once the dough has chilled and is nice and firm, it’s time for the fun part – shaping your “potatoes.” Use a teaspoon or a small cookie scoop to portion out pieces of dough. Then roll them into slightly oval, potato-shaped nuggets with your hands. You don’t have to get them perfect – real potatoes are lumpy and wonky, and that’s half the charm.

Pour your ground cinnamon into a shallow bowl. Take a few “potatoes” at a time and gently roll them around until they’re coated in cinnamon. Don’t skimp! The cinnamon is what gives them their signature look, and it also adds just the right hit of warm spice to balance the creamy sweetness inside.

Lay the finished candies on a parchment- or wax-paper-lined baking sheet. Once they’re all rolled and dusted, cover the tray loosely with plastic wrap and pop them back in the fridge until you’re ready to serve.

Serve them cold or at cool room temperature. Either way, they’ll disappear fast.

For a playful twist, try sticking a few chopped pine nuts into the tops to look like little “potato eyes” – kids love this touch. Or for a deeper flavor, roll some in a mix of cocoa powder and cinnamon. That extra depth pairs beautifully with Irish coffee or even our Irish Cream Macarons for a full-on themed dessert tray.

What to Serve with Irish Potato Candy

Irish Potato Candy may be tiny, but it packs a punch, so pair it with something light and fresh. It’s a fun addition to any St. Patrick’s Day dessert table alongside our Guinness Chocolate Cake with Irish Buttercream, which brings a bold, grown-up counterpoint to the candy’s sweetness. You can also serve them after a hearty Irish dinner like corned beef and cabbage – they make a cheeky surprise at the end of a traditional meal.

They’re also right at home with a mug of strong coffee or Irish cream liqueur (if the kids are in bed, of course). Or go full dessert board mode: include Irish Potato Candy alongside shortbread cookies, a small fruit plate, and maybe even our Strawberry Shortcake Poke Cake for a sweet spread that’s got a little something for everyone.

Key Tips for Making Irish Potato Candy

Want to guarantee success? Here are a few tried-and-true tips. First, use full-fat cream cheese – it gives the filling the rich texture you want, and the lower-fat stuff can make it too soft. Next, don’t skip the chill time. The dough really needs to firm up so you can roll it without sticking to everything in your kitchen. Also, keep your mixer on low the whole time, especially when adding sugar. Unless you want a powdered sugar facial (been there).

If your dough is still too soft to roll after chilling, pop it back in the fridge. No need to stress – this dough is forgiving. And remember, your “potatoes” don’t need to be identical. In fact, the slightly rustic look is what makes them charming. Think wonky, not Pinterest-perfect. Lastly, don’t worry if you have cinnamon left over. You’ll need enough to get a good roll, but you won’t use it all. Just scoop any clean leftovers back into the jar or use it in your next Green Cookies batch!

Storage and Reheating Tips for Irish Potato Candy

Here’s the beauty of Irish Potato Candy: it stores like a dream. Once rolled, just place the candies in an airtight container and pop them in the fridge. They’ll stay fresh and tasty for up to a week. If you want to make them ahead of time – say, for a party or gift bags – they also freeze well. Just line a container with wax paper, stack the candies in layers, and freeze.

When you’re ready to serve, thaw them overnight in the fridge. Do not microwave them – they’re meant to be enjoyed chilled or at cool room temp. Trying to reheat them will just melt the butter and make a mess (and not the good kind). If you’re storing them long-term, be sure they’re sealed tight so they don’t pick up any fridge smells. No one wants cinnamon coconut with a hint of leftover meatloaf.

FAQs

Do these actually have potatoes in them?
Nope! Not even close. Irish Potato Candy gets its name from how it looks, not what’s inside.

Can I skip the coconut?
You could try, but honestly, the coconut is what gives it that texture and flavor. If you’re not a fan, maybe try our Strawberry Cream Cheese Pastries instead – still no-bake-ish and delicious.

Is this a kid-friendly recipe?
Absolutely. They’ll love helping shape and roll the candies – just be ready for cinnamon everywhere.

Can I make a smaller batch?
Yes! This recipe halves beautifully. Just divide all the ingredients in two and follow the same steps.

Can I use margarine or low-fat cream cheese?
You can… but don’t. It changes the texture and flavor. Stick with the real stuff for best results.

Final Thoughts

Irish Potato Candy is one of those rare treats that manages to be fun, nostalgic, easy, and downright tasty all at once. It’s sweet without being cloying, quirky without being complicated, and festive without demanding hours in the kitchen.

Whether you’re Irish, Philly-born, or just love cinnamon and coconut, this no-bake candy deserves a place in your recipe rotation. Plus, it’s a great way to get kids involved in the kitchen, make sweet gifts, or just treat yourself to something different. If you’re craving more fun twists on desserts, don’t miss our No-Bake Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake or Angel Food Cake Strawberry Shortcake Jars for other crowd-pleasing ideas. Bottom line? Make these once, and you’ll be hooked. That little cinnamon-dusted “potato” might just become your new favorite holiday tradition.

Follow us on Pinterest for weekly slow cooker inspiration, or join the conversation over on our Facebook page where fellow food lovers share their favorite comfort meal.

Print